Attention

The opinions expressed by columnists are their own and do not represent our advertisers

Thursday, April 24, 2014

The Bundy Paradigm: Will You Be a Rebel, Revolutionary or a Slave?

“Those who make peaceful revolution impossible will make violent revolution inevitable.”—John F. Kennedy

Those tempted to write off the standoff at the Bundy Ranch as little more than a show of force by militia-minded citizens would do well to reconsider their easy dismissal of this brewing rebellion. This goes far beyond concerns about grazing rights or the tension between the state and the federal government.

Few conflicts are ever black and white, and the Bundy situation, with its abundance of gray areas, is no exception. Yet the question is not whether Cliven Bundy and his supporters are domestic terrorists, as Harry Reid claims, or patriots, or something in between. Nor is it a question of whether the Nevada rancher is illegally grazing his cattle on federal land or whether that land should rightfully belong to the government. Nor is it even a question of who’s winning the showdown— the government with its arsenal of SWAT teams, firepower and assault vehicles, or Bundy’s militia supporters with their assortment of weapons—because if such altercations end in bloodshed, everyone loses.

What we’re really faced with, and what we’ll see more of before long, is a growing dissatisfaction with the government and its heavy-handed tactics by people who are tired of being used and abused and are ready to say “enough is enough.” And it won’t matter what the issue is—whether it’s a rancher standing his ground over grazing rights, a minister jailed for holding a Bible study in his own home, or a community outraged over police shootings of unarmed citizens—these are the building blocks of a political powder keg. Now all that remains is a spark, and it need not be a very big one, to set the whole powder keg aflame.

More

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

"To some, the choice is clear. As psychologist Erich Fromm recognized in his insightful book, On Disobedience: “If a man can only obey and not disobey, he is a slave; if he can only disobey and not obey, he is a rebel (not a revolutionary)."

True.

Anonymous said...

The dude broke the law for 20 years. i don't know what he expected...

Anonymous said...

2:40PM How do you know he has broken the law for 20 years? Have you seen a survey of his land? I sure have not seen one produced anywhere. If his cattle stop grazing on the land who is going to pay for the upkeep?....Our tax dollars will have to pay for the upkeep.

Anonymous said...

http://www.archives.utah.gov/research/exhibits/Statehood/1894text.htm

This is the same document Nevada signed, and it;s so unconstitutional it's laughable, and Clive Bundy knows it!

This is the issue here, and it needs to be corrected in court, not out in the desert with a shootout.

Please read it before commenting further.